Steve Sailer has been an inspiration to a lot of bloggers for his tireless devotion to spreading the truth about topics such as IQ and human biodiversity. It is thus, with great disappointment and regret that I criticize his position on Sarah Palin.
For a guy who trumpeted the movie Idiocracy as the greatest cinematic accomplishment of the decade, it’s rather weird that when the movie actually comes to life in the form of Sarah Palin, he remains silent on the whole topic. And finally, after the election is over, he writes a post claiming that Palin is as smart as Biden.
Sorry Steve, that’s just not true. Biden was smart enough to graduate from law school and pass the bar exam, indicating a minimum intelligence level of one standard deviation above the norm, or a little more. Biden graduated near the bottom of the class at a mediocre law school, so he’s not a genius. I would prefer to see people smarter than Biden in public service, but at least he has enough intelligence to not be a total embarrassment to our country.
Steve has fallen for the type of blank slate analysis that he’s only too happy accuse liberals of. This analysis holds that Palin only seems less intelligent than Biden because she hasn’t been exposed to same environment. Sorry, this doesn’t cut it. There are books, newspapers, and even the internet in Alaska. If she hasn’t learned much about national affairs by the age of forty-four, nothing is going to change in another few years.
Steve Sailer also wrote that mothers are more interested in their children than things such as national and international issues. Sailer is obviously unfamiliar with Palin, because whatever she’s interested in it’s not her children. Her son Track spent his senior year of high school in Michigan, the daughter Bristol was living with her aunt in Anchorage (when she wasn’t having sex with her boyfriend or doing drugs). Three days after Trig was born, Sarah was back at work giving speeches. Bristol seems to spend a lot more time taking care of Trig than Sarah does. Sarah Palin is obviously a lot more interested in her career than her children. Not that I blame her for this. Running a state sounds a lot more interesting than changing the diapers of a retarded baby. But this disproves Steve’s theory that Sarah was too interested in her children to bone up on the issues.
Those defending Palin’s intelligence seem to be living in a state of cognitive dissonance. They can’t believe that a Republican could be of only average intelligence. This is pretty stupid analysis. The average person is of average intelligence, and the Republican Party now celebrates its appeal to average Americans and not the elites. Someone from the ranks of the average inexplicably rose to governor of a state, and was then inexplicably selected as McCain’s running mate. Those two accomplishments don’t prove her intelligence. One thing I learned from this election cycle is that voters don’t put much value in a candidate’s intelligence. Until now, there has been a behind-the-scenes selection process which weeds out people of average intelligence before any regular voters get to cast a vote. For whatever the reason, the usual process didn’t weed out Palin.
By average intelligence, I mean that half the people are more intelligent than Palin, and the other half are less intelligent. Based on the convention that the average IQ is 100, this means my estimate of her IQ is 100. This estimate shouldn’t shock anyone. After all, if you randomly selected a hundred people, the average random person would have an IQ of 100. Of course it’s highly unusual for the governor of a state to have merely an average IQ. As I wrote above, the process normally weeds out people of average intelligence. Usually, in order to get to the point where your name is on the ballot, you have to have accomplished something that requires an above average IQ. For example, most candidates for a governor of a state are rich. A disproportionate number of rich people have above average IQs. Also, governors often have prestigious educational credentials, which require above average IQs.
Sarah’s accomplishments prior to becoming governor did not require an above average IQ. Being the part owner of a snowmobile rental business, and getting elected as mayor of a town of 6,000 people, these accomplishments do not require an above average IQ. A small town election is a popularity contest, not an IQ contest. A pretty woman with a perky personality does not need a high IQ to win a popularity contest.
You don’t need an above average IQ to graduate from college, if you graduate from an easy college like the University of Idaho with an easy major like Sports Journalism, take five years to do it, and obtain a lot of your credits from community colleges. Smart people don’t attend community colleges. As I’ve written before, I get the impression she couldn’t handle the business major at Hawaii Pacific “University,” probably because she couldn’t handle the math required for such a major, and that’s why she only attended for one semester.
Let us review the other indicators of Sarah Palin’s only average intelligence:
(1) Smart people have smart children. Track isn’t going to college, and Bristol dropped out of high school. There’s no evidence that Willow is smart.
(2) Smart people marry other smart people. Sarah Palin married Todd who never finished college.
(3) Smart people make sure their teenage daughters don’t get pregnant.
(4) Smart people read newspapers and magazines. Sarah Palin couldn’t name any she reads in the interview with Katie Couric.
(5) Smart people have intellectual hobbies. Sarah Palin hunts moose. (In contrast, Biden's hobby is teaching a law class at Widener University.)
(6) Smart people who majored in journalism would have written something. Sarah Palin never wrote anything. Whatever criticism people may have of the quality of Michelle Obama’s Princeton paper, at least she put words to paper. The op-ed article that once appeared in the New York Times under Sarah Palin’s name was obviously ghost written.
(7) Smart people have smart siblings. Sarah’s sister married Mike Wooten, a guy who tasered his own stepson.
(8) Smart people have smart friends. I can’t find the link to the video of the women from Wasilla who were Sarah’s friends, but they didn’t appear to be very smart.
While there's all this evidence of Sarah Palin being only average, there's no believable evidence that she ever did anything smart. The only evidence of above average intelligence either comes from testimony from family members (the sister who married Mike Wooten says Sarah is smart), or people who are obviously sucking up to her, like the National Guard guy who got promoted right after he gave an interview praising her.
The cognitive dissonance people, the ones who can’t accept that a Republican could be any less than a genius, keep bringing up various gaffes made by Obama and Biden. A gaffe is not an indication of low intelligence. Anyone with common sense should know this. Obama accidentally saying that there are 57 states is a gaffe. Sarah Palin not understanding the difference between South Africa and southern Africa is not a gaffe, it’s an indication of a lack of reasoning ability and a lack of general knowledge.
A person's political beliefs should not be taken as an indication of high or low intelligence. Political ideologies, like religions, are memes that infect the brains of smart people. Smart people are capable of thinking logically, but often choose not to. Romney's devotion to Mormonism makes no sense, Biden's devotion to left wing causes makes no sense, but neither proves low intelligence.
Why am I still writing about this after the election? Because other people are still writing about it, because people still refuse to accept what a huge mistake it was for McCain to choose Palin, because people are even talking about Palin 2012. Until everyone realizes that Palin is not smart enough to be President of the United States, it's worth writing about.
Recent Comments